What Supreme Court review is
The U.S. Supreme Court is a court of discretionary review. It does not hear every case that is brought to it. It chooses the cases that present an important question of federal law, a conflict among the lower courts, or an issue the Court has not yet decided. A Supreme Court appeal attorney’s first job is to show the Court why your case is one of the few worth hearing.
Most Supreme Court cases arrive on a petition for a writ of certiorari, asking the Court to review a decision of a federal court of appeals or a state supreme court. The petition is a short, focused document — usually no more than 9,000 words — and it is the single most important filing in the case.
The petition for certiorari
A cert petition has one purpose: to persuade four Justices that the case deserves review. It explains the question presented, why the lower court got it wrong, why the issue matters beyond the parties, and — most importantly — whether the lower courts disagree about it. A circuit split, where different courts of appeals have decided the same question differently, is the strongest reason for the Court to grant review.
The other side files a brief in opposition, and the petitioner may file a reply. The Justices then consider the petition in conference. There is no hearing at this stage, and no argument — the papers are the whole case.
The Rule of Four
It takes four votes to grant certiorari — the Rule of Four. The Court receives roughly 7,000 petitions each term and grants about 60 to 80 of them, a grant rate of around 1 percent. Those numbers are the reality every Supreme Court appeal attorney works with, and an honest one will tell you them up front.
The cases that get granted usually have a clean record, a clear question, and a reason the Court needs to resolve the issue now. Cases with messy facts, unpreserved issues, or an alternative ground for the judgment below are almost never granted, no matter how important the question seems.
Merits briefing and argument
If certiorari is granted, the case moves to merits briefing: the petitioner’s brief on the merits, the respondent’s brief, and a reply. Amicus curiae briefs — friend-of-the-court briefs from interested organizations — are common, and a good Supreme Court attorney will recruit them. The case is then argued for one hour before the nine Justices.
Supreme Court advocacy is a specialty within a specialty. The Justices ask questions from the first minute, and the advocate must answer them directly while making the case. Former Supreme Court clerks and attorneys with prior arguments before the Court are in high demand for this work.
What to look for in a Supreme Court appeal attorney
Look for an attorney who has filed cert petitions before — ideally one who has had a petition granted — and who has argued in the Court or clerked there. Ask how many petitions they have filed, how many were granted, and whether they have handled cases in your area of law.
Also ask for a candid assessment of the certworthiness of your case. A good Supreme Court attorney will tell you when a petition is a long shot, and will help you decide whether the cost — which is substantial — is justified by the chance of review.
Frequently Asked Questions About Supreme Court Appeal Attorney
A petition for certiorari must be filed within 90 days of entry of the judgment below, under 28 U.S.C. § 2101. The deadline can be extended by up to 60 days on application to a Justice, but extensions are not automatic. Do not wait — the petition takes weeks to prepare properly.
Low, for most cases. The Court receives about 7,000 petitions a term and grants roughly 60 to 80 — about 1 percent. The odds improve significantly if there is a circuit split, an important and recurring federal question, or a decision that conflicts with the Court’s precedent. Your attorney can assess the certworthiness of your case honestly.
Yes, if the case presents a federal question — a question of federal law or the U.S. Constitution. The Supreme Court cannot review a state court decision that rests on an adequate and independent state ground. Your attorney will determine whether your case presents a federal question the Court can review.
A cert petition is expensive, because it requires a specialist and a substantial amount of work in a short time. Costs commonly run into the tens of thousands of dollars for the petition alone, and much more if the Court grants review and the case proceeds to merits briefing and argument. Ask for a written estimate before you retain counsel.
Find an Appellate Attorney in Your State
Browse certified appellate specialists and appeals lawyers in the states with the largest directories — or view all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Browse appellate attorneys in all states → · Back to the homepage